Market & Fruit picking pack. More here.
Handmade Copper Flask. More here.
New England Heirloom Seeds. More here. 
Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract. More here. 
Canadian Ash Wood Toboggan. More here. 
Texas BBQ Smoking Bags. See here.
Brooks Leather Bicycle Saddle. More here.
Wooden Snowshoes. See here.
I absolutely love Kaufmann Mercantile for their carefully selected goods, especially as they relate to sport and adventure. I think any of the above would make for excellent holiday surprises.